1. Introduction to Histopathology
An appreciation of systemic pathology is based on
the knowledge of normal and general pathology; a sound understanding of the
principles of pathology is essential for a sound physician, surgeon, and
gynecologist. A firm foundation in general and systemic pathology is very
essential for a teacher to impart teaching in pathology. The teaching and
understanding of pathology is incomplete without understanding the morphological basis of the disease, and for this, the study heavily relies on histopathology.
A clinical issue is well understood only if the underlying changes in cells and
tissues are understood. A working knowledge, a critical and a logical approach
to arrive at a diagnosis by a well-timed and a clinically oriented laboratory
investigation form the basis of the practice of diagnostic pathology. This
approach requires a thorough knowledge of the basic principles of various
facets of diagnostic pathology, e.g. cytopathology, hematology, and
immunopathology, but the most essential being understanding of histopathology.
The study of usual and unusual morphology of cells
and tissues and the structural and functional disturbances which underlie the
pathogenesis of disease come under the purview of Pathology. In recent years,
the use of advanced technology has greatly enhanced the capacity of
pathologists to accurately diagnose both the disease and the extent of the
disease. Despite this, there has been no impact on the three basic sciences
underlying diagnostic pathology, namely etiology, pathogenesis, and morphogenesis.
The basic information required to make a diagnosis is contained largely in the
morphologic and architectural disturbances of the cells and tissues that
constitute the particular disease process, and this information is imparted by
histopathology. Though there has been tremendous development in diagnostic
radiology and imaging techniques, the final diagnosis requires tissue diagnosis
in the vast majority of cases.
Histopathology is the gold standard for the
diagnosis and prognosis of most diseases. It helps to analyze and understand
the underlying causes and mechanisms of diseases, the extent and natural course
of diseases, as well as the possible outcomes of diseases. Histopathology also
helps to determine the efficacy of treatment or prevention measures and
provides a scientific basis for the classification of diseases.
1.1. Importance of Histopathology
in Pathology
Histopathology, a term derived from the Greek words
historia "tissue" and "logos" knowledge, has been
established as an important basic science which is essential in understanding
the underlying causes of disease. In more recent years, it has become an
integral part in the diagnosis of diseases and has become the basis of research
into the causation of disease and the effects of specific disease processes. An
understanding of pathology is critical for the physician setting up a
diagnosis, for it is the knowledge of the changes in the normal state which
help define the states of illness. An example to this is the physician
diagnosing a patient with arthritis. With an understanding of pathology, the
physician can deduce that the patient has inflammation of the joint, that this
is the cause of the pain and knows to look at the joint under further
examination. He can then go on to look at the precise causation of the
inflammation and ways to prevent this, with the knowledge of the changes being
the starting point for all this. In the modern day when an increasing number of
diseases can be treated or prevented but there is a lack of understanding of
the disease processes, there is an increasing requirement for a pathologist to
define the changes in the diseased states and relay these to the clinician so
that effective measures can be taken. 63% of the tests ordered by clinicians
require some input from pathology and it has been estimated that 70% of medical
decisions are based on pathology results. This shows the importance of
pathology in disease diagnosis where histopathology is the cornerstone.
1.2. Role of Histopathology in
Disease Diagnosis
The great increase in use of histopathology by
practicing physicians. Much of the study of the pathology of disease is
concerned with etiology and pathogenesis and with the mechanisms of injury or
repair. Thus, the pathologist is as much concerned with the dynamic aspects of
disease as is the biochemist or physiologist, and much information obtained
from studies in these allied fields is of great significance in understanding
the nature of morphologic changes. However, in providing a diagnosis from tissue
examination, it is to be expected that most often the pathologist will be
called upon to be the "finder of the fact", and it is this role which
has led to the greatly increased demand for tissue diagnosis and to the
realization by practicing physicians of the value of histopathology.
Histopathology deals with the examination of
tissues for the ultimate purpose of arriving at a correct diagnosis of disease.
For while it is true that the physician must at times make diagnoses and
prescribe treatment solely on the basis of his immediate impressions and
clinical findings (laboratory procedures being unavailable or too time
consuming), the fact remains that in this scientific age, patient and physician
alike demand an ever increasing degree of precision in the practice of
medicine. Thus it is that the pathologist, who so often functions as the
"physician's physician", frequently is asked to provide a tissue
diagnosis in cases where clinical impressions are in conflict, where it is a
question of therapy, or where the physician seeks to establish a prognosis. And
the practice of obtaining tissue diagnoses - which once was confined largely to
major hospital centers with a consultant service - now is quite common even
among practitioners in the general field of medicine.
1.3. Basic Principles of
Histopathology
Tissue is most commonly fixed using a 10% neutral
buffered formalin solution. After fixation, the tissue is processed through a
variety of dehydration stages using alcohols of increasing concentration to
remove water from the tissue. It is then cleared using xylene before being
infiltrated with wax. This enables the tissue to be embedded in wax blocks and
then sliced into thin sections for mounting on slides. The wax is then removed
from the tissue sections prior to staining.
Fixation is the term given to the preservation of
tissue structure and is the first stage of tissue processing. It is essential
to prevent autolysis of the tissue, which is the degradation of cellular
material by enzymes released from cell organelles following cell death.
Autolysis causes morphological changes in cell structure that can interfere
with accurate interpretation. Fixation also needs to preserve the relationship
between cells and prevent any changes in their appearance. The ideal fixative
would be one that hardens the tissue, kills microscopic organisms, and
preserves all cell components and their relationships without altering normal
morphological appearances. This is rarely achieved, and different fixatives
have specific actions on different types of tissues.
This section is concerned with describing the basic
processes of tissue preparation, including how the tissues are preserved to
maintain their structure, then how they are prepared to be suitable for
microscopic examination, and what methods are used to stain different tissues
to specifically highlight the structures within them. An understanding of these
processes is crucial for accurate interpretation of slide images and subsequent
diagnosis of any pathological changes present.
2.
Specimen Handling and Processing
Receiving and identification of specimens It is
essential to have good communication with the surgical department in order to
maintain an efficient and cost-effective service. With the introduction of
pre-operative clinical diagnosis and special investigation, there has been a
gradual increase in the amount of tissue received. The pathologist must decide
whether a specimen should be dissected immediately or whether further
communication with the clinician is required before processing the specimen.
For example, a large hernia sac referred to as suspected carcinoma may warrant
a discussion with the referring clinician before sectioning. A request form is
usually completed by the clinician, which details the patient's name, hospital
number, and the nature of the specimen. Unfortunately, these forms are often
incomplete and it is not uncommon for a specimen to arrive without any clinical
details. In an ideal situation, the pathologist and a member of the
histopathology lab would meet with the surgical team in order to clarify any
uncertainties about the specimen and to discuss special requirements for
analysis.
2.1. Receiving and Identification
of Specimens
The first step in proper tissue processing is
accurate identification of the specimen in order to properly assess the
clinical question being asked. Before accepting any specimen, it is important
that the pathology department has a clear understanding with the surgical and
clinical colleagues of what the specimen is and what tests are required on that
specimen. It is not uncommon for a specimen to arrive in the laboratory with
inadequate history or no clinical details at all. In these cases, it is
perfectly acceptable to hold the specimen and contact the clinician for further
information. However, it is important to ensure that doing this will not
compromise patient welfare, and it might be wise to have a 'holding protocol'
agreed with the clinical service so that the decision to hold a specimen can be
quickly and easily reconciled. This is particularly important in cancer
specimens where there may be a need to proceed quickly and 'holding' the
specimen might compromise the patient's best interest. A decision to hold a
specimen should always be documented, and this will include details of what was
discussed and agreed with the clinician.
2.2. Specimen Fixation and
Preservation Techniques
Formalin is an aqueous solution of formaldehyde
gas, which is the simplest aldehyde. It polymerizes nucleic acids and proteins,
and the onset of polymerization is rapid. It is a slow process which takes
approximately 18 hours for a 5mm diameter specimen. Overfixation must be
avoided, as this will cause tissue to become brittle and resistant to cutting,
and will also lead to increased pigmentation of tissue in the H&E stain.
The standard method of formalin fixation is generally regarded as the gold
standard against which other fixation techniques are measured. Other fixation
techniques are generally compared to formalin fixation to determine their effects
on tissue structure, and ability to demonstrate different antigens in
immunohistochemistry studies. This is because there is a wealth of data about
the effects of formalin fixation on tissue and cellular morphology, and much of
our understanding of normal and abnormal tissue structure is based on
formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded material.
Formalin fixation and paraffin embedding are
universally established as the methods for anatomical pathology. A
comprehensive overview of these techniques is critical to understanding the
morphology of disease. While several alternatives exist, such as freezing
tissue in liquid nitrogen and cryostat sectioning, these techniques are usually
reserved for special circumstances or research. The most appropriate fixation
and embedding methods for a particular project will depend on the goals of the
study, and will be addressed in greater detail in later sections.
2.3. Tissue Processing: From
Specimen to Slide
Once the tissue has been fixed, it must be
processed in order to allow for efficient and thorough infiltration by liquid
paraffin. This is the process by which tissue is taken from its original state
(an in vivo or fixed whole tissue), dehydrated and then permeated with a medium
that makes it possible to produce thin, interpretative slices. It is important
that the initial specimen is undamaged and is representative of the lesion so
that tissue taken for processing is orientationally correct and fit for
interpretation. The most common method of tissue processing is automated and
employs a machine that carries tissue through a series of time stages in which
it is washed in alcohol to dehydrate it and then fixed in paraffin. This is a
relatively hands-off approach with the exception of placing the tissue in
cassettes prior to processing. Some laboratories may choose to manually process
small biopsies and this can be achieved by using a tissue transfer processor in
which tissue is carried in a cassette and connected to reservoirs that can be
filled with liquid. This method is adequate for small laboratories but is not
suitable for high volume laboratories due to the time constraints.
2.4. Embedding Techniques:
Paraffin and Cryoembedding
Embedding is the process that involves orientating
a specimen in a mould so as to allow easy cutting of tissue and support during
the cutting. The choice of embedding material is important, as it determines
the ease at which the block can be cut, the quality of the resulting ribbon,
and the durability of the block for long-term storage. The two most common
types of embedding used are paraffin and cryostat embedding. Paraffin embedding
is the most common method used. The process involves dehydrating the tissue in
alcohol followed by clearing in xylene. The tissue is then infiltrated with
paraffin wax and embedded in a mould. The wax is allowed to solidify, and the
block is trimmed, ready for cutting. This method allows storage of the block
for long periods of time and is suitable for routine studies. However, during
the process of infiltrating the tissue with wax, there is considerable
shrinkage of the tissue. Cryostat embedding involves freezing the tissue in a
suitable embedding medium and storing it at a temperature suitable for cutting.
Optimal cutting is achieved when the tissue is very cold and hard, and this
method is therefore useful when examining tissue with a view to frozen section
diagnosis. Frozen section diagnosis allows rapid diagnosis during surgery and
is often used to determine surgical margins. This can be important when deciding
whether further excision of tissue is necessary. The frozen tissue is stored
for varying lengths of time, and it is possible to freeze tissue for long-term
storage. This makes cryostat embedding useful for both routine and research
material. The method is particularly useful for avoiding tissue fixation, as
this can cause masking of antigenic sites. At the ultrastructural level, frozen
sections are useful for enzyme histochemistry and immunocytochemistry.
2.5. Microtomy: Sectioning of
Tissue Blocks
Microtomy is the process by which a tissue specimen
is cut into thin slices, usually between 5-10 microns thick, in order to be
mounted on a slide and stained. The first step in microtomy is to select the
block to be cut; ideally, this would be a paraffin block, as the material is
easier to work with than frozen tissue and can be stored for years without
damage. Before cutting, the block must be firmly attached to the microtome
chuck on which it will be mounted. The microtome should then be set to the
desired thickness (usually around 5 microns) and the blade positioned for
cutting. If the block is particularly hard or soft, adjustment of the blade
angle or temperature may be necessary. Step sections are thinner than routine
sections and are taken in order to obtain the best section possible. Once cut,
the ribbon of tissue produced by the microtome may be spread on a water bath at
45°C for a few seconds in order to flatten it and then picked up by means of a
glass slide or warmed to the exact temperature at which the section will spread
without creasing. Finally, a good section is picked up and floated onto the
surface of a bath which has been previously warmed to the temperature at which
the paraffin melts.
3.
Staining Techniques
Hematoxylin and eosin staining is the most widely
used staining technique in histopathology. It is the basic and primary method
of staining done in the histopathology lab for the demonstration of general
tissue structure. The hematoxylin is a basic dye which stains nuclei of the
cell (basophilic staining) blue or purple in color. It imparts the
morphological details of the nucleus and the intensity of the staining depends
on the acidity of the nucleus. The hematoxylin which is used in the staining
process exists in the form of alum hematoxylin which in turn exists as
hematein. Hematein forms a complex with the acidic components of the cell and
stains them blue in color. But pure hematoxylin is not useful as it gives a
simple solution to staining the tissue. So mordants like aluminium potassium
sulfate or ferric ammonium sulfate are often employed to help retain the dye on
the tissue and intensify the color. Eosin on the other hand is an acidic dye
and it stains the basic components (e.g. cytoplasm, RBC, collagen) of the cell
in shades of pink and red (acidophilic staining). Eosin is less specific than
hematoxylin. It provides only little information and stains the tissue in an
ambiguous way. But it highlights the contrast provided by hematoxylin and gives
a more 3-dimensional look to the tissue. Eosin also provides the color to the
rest of the tissue so as to distinguish which has been stained by hematoxylin.
3.1. Hematoxylin and Eosin
Staining
Despite the ubiquitous usage of H&E staining,
what exactly constitutes a good H&E stained section is often difficult to
define. The interpretability of stained sections is affected by many factors
and both under and over staining can impede interpretation of tissue structure.
The section may require some empirical tuning of staining conditions until
optimal results are obtained. The skill of the histotechnologist has a marked
effect upon the final product and histotechnique is often an under-appreciated
art which directly affects the practice of surgical pathology. Within a
pathology department, installation of an internal quality control program with
regular review of H&E stains and feedback to the histotechnologist is a
constructive method to ensure maintenance of standards in H&E histology. An
example of a practical post analytic method to optimize interpretation of
H&E sections is to photocopy the section on to acetate and use different
coloured pens to mark different structural components. Difficult sections can
then be traced back to the original block and an attempt can be made to restain
it in a manner which enhances the interpretation.
Hematoxylin is a basic dye which stains basophilic
components such as nuclei, endoplasmic reticulum and ribosomes. In the presence
of acid, hematoxylin forms a complex with acidic tissue components and these
complexes are then subsequently reduced to haematin within the tissue. There
are many different formulations of hematoxylin and can be aluminium, ferric or
mercury based. Different formulations and staining times can affect the colour
of the final product. Eosin is an acidic dye which stains acidophilic
components such as cytoplasm, extracellular matrix and intracellular proteins
by forming ionic bonds.
A plethora of histochemical stains are available to
demonstrate various cellular components presenting in tissues. Hematoxylin and
eosin stains (H&E) are the most widely used stains in pathology and serve
to demonstrate general tissue structure. Thus, understanding the principles of
H&E staining and its limitations are crucial for the accurate
interpretation of histologic sections.
3.2. Special Stains for Cellular
Components
Another type of stain used for carbohydrates is the
diastase periodic acid Schiff (dPAS). This is the same as the PAS stain, but
the tissue is pretreated with diastase, which digests glycogen. This is useful
to distinguish glycogen from other carbohydrate-like substances. In dPAS
positive reactions, the substance is not glycogen.
PAS stain (Periodic Acid Schiff) is used mainly for
the detection of glycogen in cells and tissues. Glycogen is a polysaccharide of
glucose and is an important store of energy in the body. It is a normal finding
in the liver and skeletal muscles, and its presence or absence in these tissues
can be an indication of certain diseases. For example, glycogen is increased in
liver damage, diabetes, and glycogen storage diseases. It is decreased in
hypoglycemia. PAS reagent reacts with the aldehyde groups in glycogen to form
Schiff reagent, which produces a pink to magenta color in the specimen.
Special stains are used to demonstrate specific
components of cells, such as carbohydrates, lipids, and proteins. These are
usually not visible with routine H&E staining. There are many different
types of special stains, and each has its own principle and application. A few
common ones will be discussed.
3.3. Immunohistochemistry:
Detection of Antigens
Immunohistochemistry is commonly associated with
the detection of cell type-specific markers which aid in determining the
lineage of a malignant tumor. For example, cytokeratins are commonly used to
aid in the diagnosis of carcinoma as well as being used to differentiate
between the various subtypes. CD3, CD4, and CD8 are used to identify T-cells
and determine their relationship to various skin disorders.
Two primary methods of observation for
immunohistochemistry are light microscopy and immunofluorescence. The former is
widely used with diaminobenzidine. Compiled digital images of various stained
slides can be subjected to computerized analysis. This is especially useful for
quantitation of antigen expression levels.
6. Visualization. Dyes such as diaminobenzidine are
then applied to the tissue. These dyes change color in the presence of the
enzyme that is bound to the antibody complex. The reaction yields a colored
product at the antigen site, allowing its identification under a microscope.
5. Incubation with secondary antibody. The
secondary antibody is specific to the primary antibody's host. For example, if
the primary antibody is a mouse antibody, a secondary antibody that is specific
to mouse immunoglobulin is used. This step is followed by incubation with a
third reagent in some cases. Avidin and biotin are commonly used for this
purpose, as the avidin-biotin complex (ABC) has a very high binding affinity and
is not easily disrupted.
4. Incubation with primary antibody. The primary
antibody is the antibody that is specific to the antigen of interest. It is
applied to the tissue and allowed to bind to the antigen.
3. Antigen retrieval. Because fixation of tissues
with formalin and embedding in paraffin often masks antigens, this is a
critical step for immunohistochemistry done on paraffin-embedded tissues. This
can be done with enzymes or heat. Heat-induced epitope retrieval (HIER) with a
microwave or conventional pressure cooker is widely used, as it is generally
reproducible and can be optimized for different antibodies.
2. Sectioning. Tissues are embedded in paraffin and
sectioned with a microtome. The sections are then placed on slides. Some
studies have shown that freezing tissue rather than fixing with formalin yields
better results. However, frozen tissue does not preserve well and the ability
to do immunohistochemistry or any other type of staining is limited to a short
period of time following resection.
1. Fixation. This step preserves the tissue of
interest. Usually, formalin or paraformaldehyde is used as a fixative. These
agents preserve tissue structure and antigenicity.
The basic steps in an IHC staining procedure are as
follows:
Immunohistochemical (IHC) staining is used to
determine the presence and distribution of antigens in tissues. IHC is based on
the principle of antibodies binding specifically to antigens in biological
tissues. This type of staining is widely used in the diagnosis of cancer.
3.4. In Situ Hybridization:
Localization of Nucleic Acids
There are a number of possible ways in which the
hybridization signal (or the position of the probe) can be detected and these
include using either a radioactively, chemically or enzymatically labeled
probe. The most sensitive method for probe detection is the use of a
radioactive label and this can give excellent results, particularly when
combined with autoradiography. However, increasingly stringent legislation
concerning the use of radioactive materials in the laboratory and the disposal
of radioactive waste is making non-radioactive detection methods more
attractive. In situ hybridization will often be followed by the detection of
antigens or cellular components in the same tissue and in these cases it is
often useful to combine the results of the two procedures in a double label
experiment. This can be achieved by using a radioactive probe together with an
immunohistochemical detection method or by using two distinct non-radioactive
labeling techniques.
In situ hybridization is a powerful technique used
for the detection of specific nucleic acid sequences in morphologically
preserved tissues or cells. The nucleic acids can be either DNA or RNA. In situ
hybridization is achieved by allowing a labeled single-stranded RNA or DNA
molecule (the probe) to hybridize to the specific RNA or DNA sequence of the
cell or tissue under investigation. The basis of the methodology is similar to
that of Southern or Northern blot analyses, where RNA or DNA is immobilized on
a support (filter) and is then probed with a complementary sequence. In situ
hybridization on tissue sections or whole mounts of tissue is more complex and
the stringency of the reaction (or the condition necessary to give optimal
hybridization specificity) is more difficult to control. Nevertheless, the
ability to localize a specific nucleic acid sequence to a particular cell type
or region within a tissue is what makes in situ hybridization so valuable.
3.5. Electron Microscopy:
Ultrastructural Analysis
The greatest contribution of electron microscopy
has been in the classification of acute myeloid leukaemia and the diagnosis of
various renal diseases. Ultrastructural details help to classify myeloid
leukemias and dysplastic, reactive and neoplastic changes of the myeloid or
erythroid cell lines. The importance of the classification is that it provides
some prognostic information and also gives an indication of the most
appropriate therapy. For example, acute promyelocytic leukemia with the characteristic
balanced translocation involving chromosomes 15 and 17 is very responsive to
therapy with ATRA (all-trans retinoic acid). Electron microscopy is often
useful in diagnosing renal disease to identify the precise histological nature
of the condition and hence guide clinical management.
Tissue is fixed in glutaraldehyde or formalin,
embedded in plastic and ultra-thin sections are cut and stained with heavy
metals such as lead or uranium. The sections are examined in a transmission
electron microscope that can resolve structures as small as 2 nanometres.
Alternative methods include freeze-fracturing, freeze-etching and cytoskeleton
extraction.
When the resolution provided by light microscopy is
insufficient to make a diagnosis, the ultrastructural details of cells can be
revealed by electron microscopy. However, the technique is expensive and
time-consuming and its role has been considerably diminished by
immunocytochemistry and other ancillary methods.
4.
Microscopic Examination and Interpretation
After tissue sections have been prepared and
observed grossly, they are processed and stained to be viewed under the light
microscope. Light microscopy and the interpretation of findings is the
cornerstone of anatomic pathology. Histopathologic diagnosis is based upon
pattern recognition within the tissue seen at low magnification, followed by
identification of cellular details on higher magnification. Color, pattern, and
cellular abnormalities are well visualized with routine histologic staining,
and excellent correlation between the clinical presentation and the radiologic
findings and the histologic findings will usually be achieved. Hematoxylin and
eosin (H&E) is the most commonly used stain in histopathology. It provides
the basic information to diagnose most inflammatory, neoplastic and
degenerative diseases and it serves as the starting point for further
histochemical or immunocytochemical stains which may elucidate more specific
information about a particular disease process. An example might include a suspected
lymphoproliferative disorder such as Hodgkin disease. The abnormal cells are
readily apparent with H&E staining, but immunostaining for CD markers is
necessary to subtype the lymphoma and to decide on a prognosis and treatment.
This is in contrast to other imaging modalities such as radiology, in which a
specific diagnosis is often made based upon the morphologic appearance and it
is then necessary to make an inference about prognosis and treatment. In
summary, light microscopy is an inexpensive and relatively quick method to
generate a wealth of information about the patient's disease state and it will
remain the primary tool in diagnostic anatomic pathology.
4.1. Light Microscopy: Basics and
Techniques
The light microscope is a tool to enhance the
visualization of objects that are otherwise difficult to see (i.e., the details
of small structures and particles). This is achieved by magnification of the
image (making the object appear larger) and resolution. Resolution is the
ability to distinguish two very closely approximated objects as separate, or
recognition of detail. As resolution increases, the observer is able to see
smaller structures within cells and tiny aggregates of organisms, and to
discriminate fine variations in cellular morphology that are signs of specific
disease processes. In light microscopy, the upper limit of useful magnification
and resolution is about 1250x and 0.2 μm respectively. These upper limits are
rarely necessary for routine pathology work, but it is important to realize
that not all compound light microscopes are capable of this level of
performance.
While there are numerous special stains and
techniques used on tissue sections, the basic tool of diagnostic surgical
pathology is the light microscope. Yet light microscopy tends to be less
standardized among pathologists than are many of the newer tests. Although one
can look through the oculars of any microscope and see something, image
clarity, quality, and especially the ability to make valid diagnostic
interpretations are the results of understanding and skill in use of the
instrument. This chapter provides a practical guide to choosing and using a
microscope, techniques for creating good quality microscopic slides and for enhancing
image clarity, and simple methods to measure the size and other features of
microscopic objects. A proficiency in use of the light microscope and its
accessory tools will contribute greatly to making consistent and valid
interpretations.
4.2. Interpretation of Cellular
Morphology
The microscopic appearance of cells offers much
information to the diagnostic pathologist, since normal, preneoplastic, and
neoplastic cells often can be distinguished on the basis of their morphology.
At the light microscopic level, a pathologist observes the size and shape of
cells, the size, shape and staining intensity of their nuclei, the character
and color of the cytoplasm, and the architectural relationships among the
different cells within a given tissue. Ultrastructural examination with the
electron microscope provides additional information regarding the nature of
intracytoplasmic or intranuclear inclusions, the fine structure of cellular
organelles, etc. This information is essential, not only in identifying the type
and grade of tumor, but also in determining its histogenesis and in predicting
its biological behavior. In some instances, identification of neoplastic cells
is based primarily on their exclusion of normal cells. For example, in
diagnosing lymphoma, plasma cell myeloma, or metastatic carcinoma, the
neoplastic population of cells is identified by their resemblance to one of
these normal hematopoietic cells or by their site of involvement of tissue. In
certain tumors, the identification of immature or undifferentiated cells is of
diagnostic importance. An illustration of the impact of cell morphology on
tumor diagnosis is provided by the myeloproliferative disorders. The original
classification of these diseases was based on clinical, laboratory, and sometimes
pathologic features, but without regard for morphologic characteristics of
tumor cells. Subsequently, it was recognized that detailed morphologic
examination of the peripheral blood and bone marrow could provide a
reproducible means of diagnosing the different myeloproliferative diseases and
assessing their prognosis. This subsequently led to a proposal to redefine or
rename these diseases to reflect their morphologic features.
4.3. Grading and Staging of
Tumors
Tumors are unusual masses of tissue created by an
abnormal accumulation of cells. These masses can be created by a plethora of
different mechanisms, and when it comes to identifying exactly what type of
tumor a certain mass of cells represents, pathology is the definitive
discipline. When diagnosing and classifying tumors, pathologists use two
distinct processes to evaluate the tumors and reach a diagnosis - grading and
staging. These processes are used for solid tumor classification - that is,
neoplasms which have a mass form as opposed to liquid neoplasms which circulate
in the blood, i.e., leukemias. The aim of grading and staging is to appraise
the expected behavior of the tumor and to thus better plan the treatment and
eventually predict the patient's prognosis.
Grading of tumors occupies the part of tumor
classification concerning primarily the level of differentiation of a
particular neoplasm. The essential objective of grading is to estimate the
biological behavior of the tumor. Although there are a lot of different grading
systems, criteria commonly feature: 1) the degree of structural disorder in
neoplastic cells and their pleomorphism, 2) the mitotic activity of the
neoplastic cell population, 3) the level of differentiation comparing
neoplastic cells to their tissue of origin, and 4) the quantity of tumor cell
necrosis. The last item is not always included, but necrosis suggests a less
favorable outcome in the majority of neoplasms. Grading is not a simple task,
and a certain degree of subjectivity often exists. It is said that grading may
have up to 60% predictive accuracy in terms of neoplasm behavior, but this is,
of course, variable depending on the specific neoplasm.
4.4. Identification of Infectious
Agents
Identification of infectious agents, like the
diagnosis of neoplasia, is something that should be attempted in all cases not
just those where an infectious etiology is suspected. With an increasing number
of patients with iatrogenic or disease-related immunocompromise and an
increasing variety of emerging infections, identification of infectious disease
in tissue sections will continue to be an important part of pathology practice.
4.4.4. Serology and molecular diagnostics These may
be the only means of diagnosis with some infections because the organism is not
locally present in the tissue being examined. An example is in the diagnosis of
Lyme disease with detection of antibodies in the patient's serum.
4.4.3. Microbiologic culture Identification is the
ultimate goal of culture and repeated attempts with different culture media may
be needed. The use of molecular methods, especially gene sequencing is readily
available in identification of microorganisms cultured in tissues.
4.4.2. Special stains for microorganisms Many
different stains are available for the identification of microorganisms. Gram
stain and acid-fast stains are still widely used and very useful. There are
also many types of stains for identification of fungi. Immunoperoxidase stains
and in-situ hybridisation are also available for identification of specific
antigens or DNA sequences.
4.4.1. H&E stained sections Identification of
inflammation, necrosis, viral inclusions, and other cytologic alterations
indicative of possible infection. In some cases, especially with fungi, the
only finding may be necrosis with little or no agent identified.
4.5. Ancillary Techniques for
Diagnosis
Identification of specific types of infectious
agents, being bacteria, fungi, parasites or viruses can often require specific
tests which will not routinely be performed on histological sections. This may
involve simple microbiological cultures from fresh tissue, or more complex
techniques such as PCR, in-situ hybridization or serological tests. These tests
may be performed by the pathologist but more often in conjunction with a
microbiologist or virologist. They can often lead to a definitive diagnosis
after the histology has been suggestive but not conclusive.
Immunohistochemistry: this technique has become the
most widely used ancillary technique, often being referred to as a surrogate
for doing an invasive or expensive test. It involves the use of antibodies
which bind to antigens in tissue providing information on the distribution and
localization of the antigens, and is essentially an extension of traditional
enzyme and protein histochemistry but using specific antibodies. This can
provide valuable diagnostic and prognostic information and has the greatest
impact in tumor pathology.
Alternative techniques for a specific diagnosis can
be necessary when routine morphology does not lead to a definitive answer.
Newer, more sophisticated techniques are often highly targeted at a particular
diagnosis, often described as "diagnostically targeted techniques".
These can lead to a better and quicker diagnosis with less tissue from smaller
biopsies and often overcome the limitations of light microscopic findings. For
example, a common situation in diagnostic pathology is determining if a tumor
is a primary or secondary from another site. Immunohistochemistry or molecular
studies can be very helpful; another example is differentiating a non-Hodgkin
lymphoma from a poorly differentiated carcinoma - here gene rearrangement
studies can be the only way to reach a definitive answer. Ultrastructural
studies have become somewhat less used as it requires fresh tissue and the cost
effectiveness is often low, but can still be very valuable in certain
situations.
5.
Quality Assurance and Record Keeping
Standard operating procedures (SOPs) are defined as
written instructions incorporating protocols, infrastructural and utilization
decisions, and integrated in histopathology practice to standardize aspects of
practice and improve consistency. The most significant area to standardize in
histopathology practice is in the preparation of tissue for microscopic
examination, its examination, and subsequent reporting of the results.
Instituting and maintaining efficient SOPs will lead to improved turnaround
time and higher quality reporting. For example, a complex surgical specimen
(large bowel resection, cancer of the breast, lymph node biopsy) may be
examined by several different laboratory staff, and clinicians may want to know
when the tissue is expected to be reported on and any special instructions
given. These preparation protocols may be used as a teaching tool for new laboratory
or secretarial staff and are a source of information for laboratory staff.
Routine procedures are often handed down from senior to junior staff members,
and it is important to have a clear written record of what these are. Written
instructions on the preparation of individual specimens may be stored with
these specimens for retrieval and comparison with future specimens.
5.1. Standard Operating
Procedures in Histopathology
Overall a well designed and appropriately followed
SOP is an important tool to maintain and or improve the quality of the work.
- Discarding outdated and less effective work
methods. - Adherence by all staff to the specific procedure will promote a team
environment preventing isolation of work practices and it's also highly likely
that there will be someone to take over a task or method that is thought to be
effective. - Consistency of diagnostic tissue preparation between biomedical
scientists and pathologists. - Reduction of error and the repetition of work. -
Beneficial to the training of newcomers to the field.
Basically the creation of a set of standard
practices will provide the facilitation and quality driven guidelines to
produce quality pathology work. This is achieved in the following ways:
There are several published documents, which
describe the use of SOPs in histopathology laboratories all with the same basic
goal. That is, to lay down standard practices for the intended purpose of
improving the quality of the work done. The NSW Health Department has produced
a set of publications based on safe and quality work practices. This could be
very beneficial to anatomic pathologists and laboratory staff as it provides
guidelines for not only safe practices but also the hazardous and potentially
harmful substances that they might use. The Royal College of Pathologists of
Australasia has produced a document based around work practices and safety for
pathology laboratories with similar goals.
Procedures are extensively used by the scientific
community, and in the field of histopathology they are an adjunct to the
clinical diagnosis. They are the means by which pathologists and biomedical
scientists process tissue and prepare it for diagnosis. This can be via a
variety of methods and ultimately procedures are aimed at the production of a
diagnostic slide.
Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) is a written set
of step by step instructions and techniques which provides consistency and
facilitates the standardization of a specific function or operation. The aim is
to achieve the operation of a specific process in a consistent and quality
driven manner.
5.2. Quality Control and
Assurance Measures
Control is the set of procedures and practical
measures that ensure that the operations are achieved according to the plan.
Step one, therefore, is the expression of the desired level of performance,
usually documented by standard operating procedures (SOPs). In anatomic
pathology, there is little agreement about what represents desirable
performance for any particular technique or diagnosis, and some view it as an
unattainable ideal. To avoid that, a plan should have enough flexibility to
accommodate field conditions and what is feasible. The precise specification of
error is useful in this step. Error can be defined as the difference in the
performance of an operation from what was intended. The greater the disparity,
the more successful the detection of the error. This concept is important
because the first part of any QA system is error detection. The aim is to
prevent errors that have a harmful effect and to correct or attenuate one's own
errors in terms of the effects on the patient. Step two is to compare the
actual performance of an operation with the desired one. This comparison is an
ongoing process and has already been discussed in terms of monitoring. The
third step is action to maintain the desired performance. Error occurs because
of unwanted variation in the performance of an operation. Step three aims to
reduce this variation and has a very close relationship to QA.
Quality assurance (QA) is a term that has been used
in a variety of fields and applications. The aims of QA are to prevent errors,
avoid mistakes, and improve the performance of the particular system or
service. In a clinical laboratory, QA is vital. An accurate diagnosis is based
on reliable and relevant data provided by the laboratory. If such evidence is
poor, unreliable, or compromised by error in any way, the consequences can be
catastrophic. The requirement for increased regulation and accreditation, the
trend towards subspecialization, and the increasing complexity of modern
medicine have all highlighted the importance of implementing effective QA
within a laboratory. QA is best viewed as a cycle with a series of interrelated
steps: monitoring performance by the use of internal audit and the development
of performance indicators, addressing any identified problems, and improving
performance.
5.3. Maintenance of Laboratory
Records
There are various types of documents generated in a
histopathology laboratory, ranging from patient request forms, tissue
cassettes, blocks, slides, stained sections, reports, and quality control
records. It is essential for the pathology service that all these records are
retained for an appropriate length of time. Patient request forms and report
records should be retained for the patient's lifetime. Other records should be
retained for a minimum of 10 years, or in the case of a child, until the age of
25. These retention times are in line with The Royal College of Pathologists'
guidelines. Specific diseases or types of analysis may necessitate longer
retention times for some records. All documents and other records need to be
stored in a manner that allows easy retrieval. This applies to both active and
archived records, which need to be kept in conditions that prevent
deterioration. In the case of paper records, this means storage in a clean, dry
environment with protection from vermin and destruction by fire or water.
Archived records should be boxed, and the box clearly labeled with the contents
and the date range for the records. In some cases, it may be appropriate to
scan documents and store them in a digital format. This has benefits in terms
of ease of retrieval and protection of the original documents, but there are legal
issues, and these documents would still need their minimum retention periods.
It is important to continuously monitor all documents and records to ensure
their quality and to prevent loss or damage. This should be built into the
laboratory's quality management system with regular internal audits of records
management.
5.4. Digital Imaging and
Archiving of Slides
A major step was the development of affordable and
versatile digital cameras for photomicrography, although these have limited
application for routine diagnosis and are not ideal for capture of an entire
slide. More recently, scanning devices specifically for the purpose of creating
a digital version of a whole slide have become available. The concept is
analogous to the digitization of music into a file which can be played back
with no loss of quality, even though the file is much smaller than the original
source. Digital slides have the advantage that they can be viewed on a computer
monitor and easily shared via the internet.
In modern day histopathology, archiving and
management of slides is an important issue. Many pathologists and laboratories
maintain thousands, even millions of glass slides and reports. These require
storage space and there are issues relating to retrieval and movement of slides.
Maintenance of slide quality over decades is critical for the diagnosis and
understanding of disease processes. Furthermore, in today's multidisciplinary
practice, cases are reviewed and reported many years after the original
diagnosis. The use of digital technology provides a potential solution to many
of these problems without compromising the quality of the material.
5.5. Ethical Considerations in
Histopathology
Ethical considerations in histopathology are
especially important as pathologists are dealing with patient material and
information which is often irreplaceable. For example, a surgical resection
which results in the histological diagnosis of benign tissue will mean that no
further treatment is required. However, if a different pathologist re-examining
the same specimen interprets the findings as malignant, the consequences are
considerable (Okonkwo et al., 2002). It is important in this situation that the
patient's best interests are maintained. This can occur through documentation
of the macroscopic and histological features of the specimen which ideally
should be in the form of photographs and drawings, as descriptions alone can be
vague and open to misinterpretation. These images can then be stored within a
clinico-pathological database for future reference. An internal second opinion
can also be sought as to whether the material should be sent to an external
source for consultation.
6. Future
Directions in Histopathology
Advancements in technology have significantly
influenced the practice of histopathology and are likely to continue to do so.
One of the most notable changes in pathology practice has been the development
of digital pathology. This involves the capture of a glass slide (whole slide
image; WSI) into a digital format, allowing the image to be viewed on a
computer screen. Its potential applications are wide ranging and it is
envisaged that digital pathology will eventually replace the microscope in
surgical pathology. Initial developments focused on utilizing digital images for
teaching and it is now possible to build image banks to aid undergraduate and
postgraduate learning. Diagnostic work has been revolutionized with the
possibility of utilizing telepathology, enabling pathologists to view and
report on cases from any location with an internet connection. This has
particular benefits for pathologists working in different hospitals or
laboratories, and for those seeking expert opinion on difficult cases. The main
drive behind the development of digital pathology is the potential improvement
in working practices and patient care that can be achieved by the increased
efficiency in handling and accessing digital images when compared to
conventional glass slides. This includes the automation of image analysis and
the development of computer aided diagnosis (see Section 6.2). Although the
technology has been available for over a decade, issues regarding validation,
standardization, and cost have meant that its uptake has been slow. However,
recent years have seen greater awareness of the technology and a realization of
its potential benefits, and it seems likely that digital pathology will
eventually become an integral part of pathology practice.
6.1. Advancements in Digital
Pathology
A National Health Service (NHS) health technology assessment
reported that there were compatibility issues with existing systems and it was
difficult to calculate the costs and benefits of implementing digital
pathology. It was concluded, however, that the capabilities and predicted
advancements in the near future made information technology in pathology
inevitable.
Most recently, digital pathology has been the
forerunner in the transition from an analogue practice to a digital one. More
recently, cell analysis has been done by acquiring digital images (virtual
slides) of the histopathological glass slides. This is usually done with an
automated device that is able to scan the slides. Virtual slides can be viewed
on a computer using software that simulates a microscope. This technology is
already widely used for educational purposes and is set to replace the optical
microscope as the primary tool for diagnosis. The ability to share digital
images between professionals has opened up interesting possibilities for
telepathology. This is a practice where a pathologist can interpret the images
at a remote location. This could be a very beneficial service for overseas labs
as well as to obtain an expert opinion.
Pathology and its sub-specialty, histopathology,
are the study and diagnosis of disease. This involves describing and
interpreting the cause and effect of disease. The best results are often
obtained by meticulous observation of cells and tissues, often with the use of
a microscope. Recent advances in computer technology have opened an array of
possibilities to further improve results as well as streamline the workload of
pathologists.
6.2. Automation and Artificial
Intelligence in Histopathology
Automation in histopathology involves the use of
either robotic technology or computer-controlled devices to perform tasks
normally done by pathologists. Robotics research in histopathology is still in
its infancy; however, automated vision technologies are already allowing
cell-by-cell analysis to be carried out in a manner that frees the human raters
from this tedious task. Artificial intelligence is the capability of a device
to imitate intelligent human behavior. It is a diverse subject covering a wide
range of machine capabilities and applications. Expert systems are already
being developed to provide diagnostic assistance; some are no more than
algorithmic pathways with no true AI, while others are based on machine
learning and complex data analysis. The potential exists for AI to automate
diagnostic processes in histopathology, and although it still remains an emerging
concept, its implications are already creating unease among pathologists who
fear for the security of their jobs.
6.3. Integration of Molecular
Pathology
Histopathology is a complex discipline that
involves the use of many different techniques to make a diagnosis. It seeks to
observe the manifestations of the disease process in tissues in order to
understand the pathobiology and to arrive at a diagnosis. The integration of
molecular pathology into the framework of the standard practices of surgical pathology
is now an essential feature of a histopathologist's work. It is rare now to see
a research paper published that does not have some form of molecular study and
these results are always interpreted in the context of the disease process. In
the clinical setting, the findings often have therapeutic and predictive
implications and in many cases can be used to tailor the treatment of an
individual patient. It is not our role to describe the techniques of molecular
pathology, but rather to consider how the molecular information relates to the
tissue findings and how it can be integrated into diagnostic practice. Many
disease processes occur as a result of an abnormality in gene transcription and
protein synthesis within cells and molecular studies are often aimed at
understanding these processes. The traditional approach of the histopathologist
has been to study the abnormal cells in situ and to interpret the changes in
the context of the morphology and the clinical findings. The identification of
specific morphological changes often leads to further hypothesis-driven studies
aimed at understanding the underlying pathobiology and it is at this point that
the information from molecular studies becomes highly relevant. In some cases,
the molecular information will directly elucidate the morphological changes
observed. An understanding of the link between human papilloma virus infection
and overexpression of p16 protein leading to cervical intraepithelial neoplasia
is one such example and it is now common for histopathologists to order
immunohistochemistry for specific molecular markers in order to aid diagnosis.
6.4. Emerging Techniques for
Tissue Analysis
6.4.3 Microscale technologies New microscale
technologies such as microfluidics and microarrays offer the ability to break
down complex biological systems into more simple and analyzable components.
This could potentially bring analysis close to the in-vivo state of the tissue
and reduces the amount of tissue required for analysis. Although these
techniques are not specific to tissue analysis, their impact on the study of
disease and disease models will inevitably change the way we look at and
understand disease processes in tissues.
6.4.2 In-vivo molecular imaging Imaging techniques
are a key diagnostic tool in modern medicine and in-vivo molecular imaging is a
natural progression in medical imaging. It is a rapidly evolving field that can
be broadly defined as visualization of endogenous molecular processes in living
organisms. Though its primary use is in preclinical research, the prospect of
correlating imaging findings with histological and molecular information is an
attractive one. This should eventually lead to tissue specific diagnoses and
the ability to monitor specific disease processes in an individual patient.
6.4.1 MALDI mass-spectrometry imaging
Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI TOF) mass
spectrometry (MS) is a powerful proteomic technique for the discovery of
protein and peptide biomarkers between normal and diseased tissues. MALDI MSI
extends the capability of MALDI MS analysis to provide the preservation and
analysis of the spatial distribution of biomolecules directly in tissue,
providing a direct correlation of locational pathology with molecular
pathology.
The potential impact of a better understanding of
disease and drug mechanism through the discovery of new biomarkers, drug
targets, and efficacy/toxicity assessment is enormous. New technologies are
driving a major change in the way tissue analysis will be performed in the not
too distant future. As the traditional model of histopathologist as sole
analyser of tissue on read only glass slides gives way to pathologists as
integrators of information from multiple sources, there will be a greater need
for interdisciplinary interactions. Molecular biologists, chemists, information
technologists and engineers will all be part of the new multidisciplinary team
involved in tissue analysis.
6.5. Challenges and Opportunities
in Histopathology
There are many challenges and opportunities in
histopathology, some of which have been discussed in previous sections. The
challenge to the discipline is to maintain a focus on the tissue and
morphological diagnosis in the face of increasing complexities ranging from
molecular biology to big data derived from clinical trials. An important
opportunity lies in the potential to integrate findings from other methods of
tissue analysis with the light microscope-based diagnosis. This should enable
tissue diagnosis to remain the key reference point in anatomic pathology
offering a durable linkage between clinical and basic science. The implications
of this linkage will be the subject of ongoing study and debate. The rapid pace
of technological change will continue, and histopathology is likely to evolve
in a range of different subspecialised areas. Some new techniques may not be
disseminated widely, and it will remain important to critically appraise their
utility while ensuring that the core disciplines of anatomic pathology are
maintained.